Academe Learn
CBME Curriculum Preview

Page 13 of 13

CM12.1-5 | Geriatric Services — PBL Case

CLINICAL SETTING

It is a busy Monday morning at the Rangapur PHC in a semi-rural district of Karnataka. Dr. Priya, the medical officer, is reviewing the home-visit register when ANM Kavitha arrives with an elderly man and his neighbour. 'Doctor, I found Mr. Venkatappa, 72 years old, sitting alone on his porch at 8 AM. He had not eaten since yesterday and looked confused,' she says. 'His daughter lives in Bengaluru — she called last week saying he had fallen twice recently but refused to come to the PHC.' The neighbour adds: 'He used to run the primary school here for 30 years. Now he doesn't recognise some of us. He gives away his belongings. His son visits once a year at Diwali.'

Trigger 1: The Presenting Crisis

Dr. Priya examines Mr. Venkatappa. He is oriented to person but not to time or place. He does not know today's date or the name of the current state Chief Minister, though he vividly recalls his teaching years. Vitals: BP 158/94 mmHg, pulse 88/min, RR 18/min, temperature 37.2°C, SpO2 96% on room air. He is thin (weight 52 kg, height 168 cm, BMI 18.4 kg/m2). He reports no pain. His neighbour says he takes 'a white tablet for sugar' and 'some sleeping tablet from the city doctor' given 4 months ago. He walks slowly into the examination room without a stick. Dr. Priya performs a brief TUG test: he takes 19 seconds. She notes a healing bruise over his right forearm consistent with a recent fall.

DISCUSSION POINTS

  • What are the possible explanations for Mr. Venkatappa's confusion and disorientation? Generate at least 4 differential diagnoses, ranking from most to least likely.
  • What additional history would you take from Mr. Venkatappa and his neighbour to narrow your differential? Who else would you contact?
  • What does a TUG score of 19 seconds indicate? What is the clinical significance of this finding in the context of his recent falls?
  • Identify the geriatric syndromes present or strongly suspected at this point in the case.
Click to reveal Trigger 2: Investigations and History Clarified (discuss previous trigger first!)

Trigger 2: Investigations and History Clarified

Dr. Priya contacts Mr. Venkatappa's daughter by phone. She reports: 'He has had memory problems for about 18 months, slowly getting worse. He was prescribed alprazolam 0.5 mg nightly by a private doctor in the city 4 months ago for nervousness and sleep. He takes metformin 500 mg twice daily for diabetes.' Blood tests at the PHC laboratory show: FBS 138 mg/dL, Hb 10.2 g/dL (MCV 72 fL — microcytic), serum sodium 128 mEq/L, serum creatinine 1.8 mg/dL (eGFR 38 mL/min/1.73m2). Urine dipstick: trace protein, no nitrites. Dr. Priya performs MMSE: score 19/30. She notes he completed only 5th standard education. GDS-15 score: 8/15. Chest auscultation is clear. No papilloedema. No focal neurological deficits.

DISCUSSION POINTS

  • Interpret the laboratory findings. Which single result most urgently demands intervention, and why?
  • How does Mr. Venkatappa's 5th-standard education affect your interpretation of his MMSE score of 19? What would you do differently?
  • Alprazolam is a benzodiazepine. Explain its pharmacological risk in an elderly patient with reduced renal function (eGFR 38). Which geriatric prescribing principle applies?
  • A GDS-15 of 8/15 suggests probable depression. Could his hyponatraemia alone explain his cognitive and mood findings? How would you distinguish?
Click to reveal Trigger 3: Care Planning — From PHC to NPHCE (discuss previous trigger first!)

Trigger 3: Care Planning — From PHC to NPHCE

Dr. Priya decides on the following immediate steps: she asks the ANM to call Mr. Venkatappa's daughter urgently; she discontinues alprazolam; she arranges IV normal saline for hyponatraemia correction and refers him to the district hospital for further management. The district hospital geriatric OPD physician confirms early Alzheimer's disease and iron-deficiency anaemia. Hyponatraemia resolves within 48 hours with fluids and alprazolam withdrawal — confirming it was SIADH likely secondary to the benzodiazepine. Three weeks later, Mr. Venkatappa returns to the PHC. He is now more alert (MMSE 23/30 with education-adjusted scoring), is on iron supplementation, donepezil 5 mg for early Alzheimer's, and has resumed daily walks with his neighbour. His daughter will visit monthly. Dr. Priya now needs to enrol him in the NPHCE programme and plan long-term community geriatric care.

DISCUSSION POINTS

  • Map Mr. Venkatappa's ongoing care needs to the four NPHCE tiers. Which tier is responsible for each element of his care going forward?
  • Design a primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention plan for Mr. Venkatappa, citing at least one specific intervention at each level.
  • What strategies would you use as the PHC medical officer to identify other elderly individuals in Rangapur who might have similar unmet needs? Reference the CM12.5 competency on early needs identification.
  • Mr. Venkatappa's daughter lives 300 km away and is concerned about her father's safety. What community-based support systems and NPHCE resources can you activate?

Group Task Assignments

Group 1: Geriatric Syndromes and Atypical Presentation

  • Define each geriatric syndrome identified in the case (falls, confusion, frailty, nutritional decline) with its canonical definition.
  • Explain the 'geriatric presentation paradox' with reference to Mr. Venkatappa's clinical course.
  • Prepare a 5-minute presentation for your group explaining why Mr. Venkatappa did NOT present with classic symptoms of his conditions.

Competencies: CM12.1, CM12.2

Group 2: Geriatric Pharmacology — Benzodiazepine Risk and Deprescribing

  • Review the pharmacokinetics of benzodiazepines in the elderly, focusing on volume of distribution, hepatic metabolism, and renal clearance changes with ageing.
  • Identify why alprazolam is associated with SIADH and how reduced renal function (eGFR 38) worsens drug accumulation in this patient.
  • Propose a structured deprescribing plan for alprazolam, including non-pharmacological sleep interventions appropriate for rural India.

Competencies: CM12.2

Group 3: Screening Tool Application and MMSE Education Bias

  • Compare MMSE, MoCA, and HMSE (Hindi Mental State Examination) for community use in India — tabulate their educational requirements and validation status.
  • Explain the education-adjusted MMSE interpretation and how to apply it for Mr. Venkatappa (5th standard education).
  • Design a brief community-level CGA protocol (15 minutes) for an ANM to administer during household visits, selecting the most appropriate validated tools.

Competencies: CM12.5

Group 4: Prevention Levels and Community Intervention Design

  • Map all preventive interventions discussed in the case to the three levels of Leavell and Clark's prevention model.
  • Design a fall-prevention programme for elderly residents of Rangapur, specifying primary, secondary, and tertiary interventions and the personnel responsible at PHC level.
  • Identify which NPHCE programme components would fund or support the fall-prevention programme.

Competencies: CM12.3, CM12.4

Group 5: NPHCE Programme Structure and Referral Pathway

  • Describe all four NPHCE tiers and their specific geriatric services, using Mr. Venkatappa's care journey as a worked example of each tier's role.
  • Create a referral pathway flowchart: sub-centre identification → PHC assessment → district hospital → regional geriatric centre, annotating services at each tier.
  • Research the Elderline (14567) and the National Policy for Older Persons 1999 — explain how these complement NPHCE in protecting Mr. Venkatappa's social and legal rights.

Competencies: CM12.4

Learning Issues

Research these questions and bring your findings to the discussion.

  1. [CM12.1] Define geriatric services and describe the specialty of geriatrics. How does it differ from internal medicine in its approach to the elderly patient?
  2. [CM12.2] Describe the major physical, mental, and psychosocial health problems of the elderly Indian population. Explain the multi-factorial causation of falls as a geriatric syndrome.
  3. [CM12.3] Apply the three levels of prevention (Leavell and Clark) to the health problems of the elderly. Give specific examples of primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention strategies.
  4. [CM12.4] Describe the National Programme for Health Care of the Elderly (NPHCE) — its objectives, four-tier structure, specific services at each tier, and monitoring indicators.
  5. [CM12.5] Describe the validated screening tools used for comprehensive geriatric assessment (MMSE, GDS-15, TUG, Katz ADL, Lawton-Brody IADL). Explain the MMSE education limitation and how to address it in the Indian community context.