Page 6 of 12
PS9.2 | LGBTQA+ Inclusive Psychiatric Practice — SDL Guide (Part 3)
Self-Assessment — Professional Integration of Principles
A clinician who has absorbed the content of this module should be able to articulate, with confidence and precision, the following positions — and to act on them without hesitation in clinical practice.
On the legal position: consensual same-sex relations between adults in India are not criminal (Navtej Johar, 2018). The judgment read down Section 377 IPC — it did not repeal it entirely, and Section 377 still covers non-consensual acts and acts with minors. Transgender persons have the right to self-identify their gender (NALSA, 2014) and are protected under the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act 2019 and the MHCA 2017. Same-sex marriage is not currently recognised as a right in India (Supriyo, 2023). A clinician who is not certain of these facts is not ready to counsel a patient or their family on their legal rights — and a patient who has been counselled incorrectly may make decisions with serious life consequences.
On ICD-11 and medical classification: there is no ICD-11 diagnosis based on sexual orientation. Homosexuality is not a mental disorder. Gender incongruence has been moved from the mental disorders chapter to Chapter 17 (Conditions Related to Sexual Health) — it is not a mental disorder, but the classification enables access to care. Any psychiatric diagnosis must rest on evidence of suffering, functional impairment, and criterion-threshold — not on identity.
On conversion therapy: it is not a legitimate clinical option under any circumstances. It is unethical, harmful, and condemned by the NMC, WPA, and WHO. A psychiatrist approached to provide or recommend it must decline, explain the evidence base, and offer appropriate alternatives.
On clinical conduct: every patient is entitled to be addressed by their chosen name and pronouns, to have their sexual orientation and gender identity kept confidential, to receive care free from discrimination, and to have their psychiatric problems — including those driven by minority stress — assessed and treated competently. The MHCA 2017 codifies these rights. An inclusive clinical environment is not aspirational — it is a legal and professional obligation.
The self-assessment test of true competency in this domain is not whether you can recite the judgment years but whether, in the moment of a difficult consultation — when a family is hostile, when a colleague is dismissive, when the patient is testing whether you are safe — you hold the line. This requires the combination of legal knowledge, ethical clarity, and personal commitment to your duty of care that this module has sought to build.
CLINICAL PEARL
'First, do no harm' has a specific meaning in this domain. For an LGBTQA+ patient, harm can come not from the wrong prescription but from a wrong word: misgendering a transgender patient after being told their pronouns, recording 'homosexuality' as a diagnosis, or failing to challenge a colleague's discriminatory remark in a ward round. Affirmative care requires active positioning — the clinician creates the safe space; the patient should not have to fight for their dignity within a healthcare setting. Know the law. Use the correct language. And when in doubt about the right clinical formulation, ask yourself: 'Would I frame this the same way if the patient were heterosexual and cisgender?' If the answer is no, reconsider your framing.