Page 7 of 8
AS1.1-4 | Anaesthesiology as a Specialty — Assignment
CLINICAL SCENARIO
The student will produce a structured clinical portfolio that documents and critically analyses the anaesthesiologist's multi-domain role across four clinical scenarios drawn from real or simulated hospital practice: (1) a pre-operative assessment case, (2) an obstetric labour analgesia case, (3) an ICU management case, and (4) a case involving ethical decision-making in anaesthesia. For each scenario the student identifies the anaesthesiologist's specific functions, the competencies invoked, and the ethical principles engaged. The portfolio concludes with a brief reflective note on career pathway implications. This deliverable trains future clinicians to recognise, request, and refer appropriately to anaesthesiological expertise across the full breadth of the specialty.
Instructions
- Select or construct four brief clinical scenarios (3–5 sentences each) — one for each domain: (a) peri-operative care/pre-operative optimisation, (b) labour analgesia/obstetric anaesthesia, (c) ICU or acute resuscitation, (d) an ethical dilemma in anaesthetic consent or refusal.
- For each scenario, identify: the specific anaesthesiologist role (citing AS1.2 domains), what the anaesthesiologist assessed or did, and the patient outcome or decision made.
- For the ethics scenario (d), explicitly name the ethical principle(s) involved (autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, justice, veracity) and explain how the anaesthesiologist balanced competing obligations.
- Write a 150–200 word reflective note: What surprised you about the breadth of anaesthesiology? How might awareness of these roles influence your own clinical practice as a future doctor?
- Conclude with a 100-word 'career snapshot' on one anaesthesiology subspecialty (of your choice) — describing its typical work, training pathway in India, and one reason it appeals to you.
- Compile the portfolio as a continuous document with clearly labelled sections. Cite at least one reference (Morgan & Mikhail's Clinical Anesthesiology or Ajay Yadav's Short Textbook of Anaesthesia).
Length: 600–900 words total (four scenarios ~250 words, reflective note ~150–200 words, career snapshot ~100 words)
Grading Rubric — Anaesthesiology as a Specialty Assignment Rubric
| Criterion | Points | Full-marks descriptor |
|---|---|---|
| Accuracy and completeness of multi-domain role identification (AS1.2): all four scenarios correctly identify the specific anaesthesiologist role and functions | 20 pts | All four domains correctly identified with specific functions; no conflation of roles (e.g., peri-operative vs ICU clearly distinguished) |
| Ethical analysis (AS1.3): correct identification and application of ethical principles to the ethics scenario, including tension between competing principles | 20 pts | All relevant principles named correctly; tension (e.g., autonomy vs beneficence) explicitly analysed; consent framework accurately described (anaesthetic consent independent of surgical) |
| Reflective depth and critical thinking: the reflective note demonstrates genuine engagement, not surface description; connects role awareness to future clinical behaviour | 15 pts | Reflection is specific and personal; identifies a concrete change in clinical thinking or referral behaviour; goes beyond restating SDL content |
| Career snapshot quality (AS1.4): subspecialty accurately described with correct training pathway and a credible personal rationale | 10 pts | Subspecialty accurately described; Indian training pathway correct (MD → fellowship/DM); personal rationale clear and specific |
| Presentation quality: logical structure, clarity of language, within word-count guidance, reference cited | 10 pts | Well-structured with labelled sections, clear writing, within 600–900 words, at least one reference correctly cited |
PEER REVIEW
Review your peer's portfolio using the following checklist: (1) Does the pre-operative scenario describe the anaesthesiologist's role as a peri-operative physician — not only intraoperative delivery? (2) Is the obstetric scenario clearly about labour analgesia and distinct from a surgical case? (3) Does the ICU scenario go beyond 'airway management' to describe haemodynamic or ventilator management? (4) In the ethics scenario, is at least one named ethical principle correctly applied, and does the student address the concept of independent anaesthetic consent? (5) Is the reflection personal and specific (not just a summary)? (6) Is the career snapshot factually plausible for India? Provide at least two specific, constructive comments — one strength and one area for improvement.